Consistency in prosecutors' demands for criminal acts of fraud seen from the dominis litis principle is very important
Keywords:
Criminal Disparity, Criminal Offense, FraudAbstract
Criminal disparity refers to dissenting judgments regarding the same criminal act or one that possesses dangerous characteristics, both of which can be compared without clear justification. This research aims to understand and analyze whether the existence of disparities in prosecution can fulfill the legal perspectives's objectives and to identify and analyze the factors causing disparities in prosecution in Cases Number: 176/Pid.B/2019/PN Gto and Cases Number: 163 /Pid.B/2019/PN Gto by using a normative research method with a case approach. The technique employed involves a literature review supported by descriptive analysis a supplementary method. The research findings are as follows: firstly, in both verdicts, Number 176/Pid.B/2019.PN Gto and Number 163/Pid.B/2019/PN Gto, it is observed that they still do not fully meet the legal perspective's objectives because there are legal objectives that remain unfulfilled. Second, both verdicts contain factors influencing the occurrence of disparities in prosecution, including the consequences caused, considerations from the practitioner's perspective, personal factors, aggravating and mitigating circumstances, and the extent of the losses incurred.
Downloads
References
Abul Khair and Mohammad Ekaputra, 2011, Criminal Justice , Medan, USU Press
Achmad Sulchan, 2017, Public Prosecutor's Prosecution Mechanism for Child Crimes , Journal of Islamic Law Studies and Research, Vol.1 No.1
Alfira, 2012, The Right to Prosecute and Carry Out Crimes , Jakarta, Self-help group spreader
Ana Aniza Karunia, 2022, Law Enforcement of Corruption Crimes in Indonesia from the Theory Perspective of Lawrence M. Friedman) , Journal of Law and Economic Development, Vol.10, No.1
Andrisman T, 2009 Criminal Law, Principles and Basic Rules of Indonesian Criminal Law, University of Lampung
Arief B. N, 1984, Sari Lecture on Criminal Law II, Bandung, Undip Faculty of Law
Arief B. N, 1996, Anthology of Criminal Law Policy, Bandung, Citra Aditya Bakti
Arif Maulana, Public Prosecutor's Charges Against the Defendant Related to the Concept of Vindicative Justice According to Natural Law Philosophy in Criminal Cases Number: 372/PID.B/2020/PN.JKT.UTR, Legal Fatwa Journal, Vol.4 No. 4
Asikin Jainal, 2012, Introduction to Indonesian Legal System , Jakarta, Rajawali Press
Bambang Sutiyoso, 2010, Searching for the Ideal Format of Decision Justice in Judiciary, Law Journal, Vol.2, No. 2,
Benny Leonard Saragih, 2019, Disparities in Prosecution in Criminal Cases of Persecution in the Penal System in Indonesia, Scientific Journal of Master of Law, Vol 1 No.1
Chainur Arrasjid, 2008, Basics of Legal Science , Jakarta, Sinar Graphics
Chazawi Adam , 2012, Lessons Law Criminal Part 1 Stelsel Criminal , Offense Criminal , Theories Punishment , and Limits of Application Law Criminal , Jakarta: PT Raja Grafindo homeland
Chazawi Adam, 2003, Crimes Against Property, Malang, Bayu Media
Chazawi Adam, 2007, Criminal Law Lesson 1, Jakarta, PT. King Grafindo
Chintya Devi, Legal Study of Revocation of Political Rights for Perpetrators of Bribery Corruption Based on the Theory of Legal Certainty , Final Project Journal, Vol.1 No. 1
Dhaniar Eka Budiyastanti, 2017, Legal Protection for Victims of Internet Fraud Crimes , Jurnal Cakrawala Hukum, Vol.8 No.1
Accessed at http://repository.uib.ac.id/3153/5/k-1651050-chapter2.pdf , 15 November 2023 at 10.00
Accessed at http://repository.umy.ac.id on May 20, 2023 at 15:20
Accessed at https://devidarmawan.wordpress.com/ problems of disparities, accessed on January 12 2024
Accessed at https://komisi-kejaksaan.go.id/revisi-uu-kejaksaan-tuntutan-konstitusi-atas-kepastian- Hukum-yang-berkeadilan/, 19 February 2024
Dimas Indiyanto Wahyudi, Implementation of the Basic Considerations of Public Prosecutors in Determining the Severity of Criminal Charges Against Defendants in Corruption Crime Cases , Vol. 10. No. 1
Effendi Erdianto, 2011, Indonesian Criminal Law, Bandung, Refika Aditama
Hamza Andi, Certain Offenses (Special Offenses), in the Criminal Code, Jakarta, Sinar Graphics
Harahap Zairan, 2014, State Administrative Court Procedure Law, Jakarta, PT. Raja Grafindo Persada
Harkristuti Harkrisnowo, 2003, Reconstruction of the Concept of Punishment: A Lawsuit Against the Legislative and Sentencing Process in Indonesia , Jakarta, National Law Commission
Hendi Sumadi , 2015, Obstacles in Overcoming Criminal Acts of Electronic Transaction Fraud in Indonesia, Journal of Legal Insights, Vol.33, No.3
Ifdhal Kasim, 2000, Liberating the Law , Introduction to the Journal of Transformative Social Sciences "Discourse", 6th Edition Year II
Indra F. Dalimunthe, Fenty U. Tyulawa, Fence M. Wantu, 2021, Criminal Law Prosecution Design in the Criminal Justice System in the Future, Philosophia Law Reviev, 1(1)
Indra F. Dalimunthe, Fenty U. Tyulawa, Fence M. Wantu, 2021, Criminal Law Prosecution Design in the Criminal Justice System in the Future, Philosophia Law Reviev, Vol. 1, No. 1
Ismail Syam, Legal Analysis of the Public Prosecutor's Considerations in Determining the Severity of the Charges Against the Defendant in Narcotics Crimes, Vol. 4, no. 2
Criminal Code, Article 378
Supreme Court Research and Development, 2010, Position and Relevance of Jurisprudence to Reduce Disparities in Court Decisions Legal and Judicial Research Center of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Indonesia, Jakarta, Supreme Court
Marlya Rettta Bangun, 2022, Disparity in Prosecution by Public Prosecutors Against Narcotics Abusers in the Toba Samosir District Prosecutor's Office , Journal of Doctrine Review, Vol.1 No.1
Mertokusumo Sudikno, 1999, Getting to Know the Law, Yogyakarta, Liberty
Moeljotno, Principles of Criminal Law, Jakarta, Rineka, Cipta
Muhammad Nafi, 2020, Application of Justice Theory in Joint Property Decisions (Case Analysis Number 0346/Pdt.G/2017/PA.Ktb), Hadratul Madaniyah Journal, Vol.7, Issue 1
Muladi and Arief B. N, 2010, Criminal Theories and Policies, Bandung, Ed. I, Fourth printing
Muladi and Arief B. N, 2010, Criminal Theories and Policies, Bandung, Ed.1, Third Printing
Muladi and Arief B. N, Criminal Theories and Policies, Bandung
Naomi Artadinata, Arrangements of Public Prosecutors in Handling Corruption Crimes Based on the Dominus Litis Principle, Journal of Criminal Law, Vol.4 No.3
Napitupulu, 2018, Application of the Opportunity Principle in Relation to the Duties and Authorities of the Prosecutor's Office in the Criminal Justice System (Study of the Case Against the Defendant Novel Bin Salim Baswedan), Tangjungpura Law Journal, Vol.2, Issue 1,
Noor Rahmad, 2019, Legal Study of Online Fraud Crimes, Journal of Sharia Economic Law Vol. 3 No. 3
Nurbadri . 2010 , Enforcement Law , Academia Journal , Jakarta
Prakoso Djoko, 1984, Duties and Roles of Prosecutors in Development, Jakarta, Ghalia
Pratasis , SO 2014 Implementation Theory Justice Commutative To Perpetrator Rape According to Article 285 of the Criminal Code . Lex Et Societatis Journal , Vol.2 No.5
Prodjodikoro Wirjono, 2003, Certain Criminal Offenses in Indonesia , Bandung, Refika Adityama
Rahmad , N. , 2019 , Study law to follow criminal fraud online , J ournal Law Economy Sharia , Vol.3 No. 2
RB Budi Prastowo, 2006, Formal Material Offenses, The Nature of Against Formal/Material Laws and Criminal Liability in Corruption Crimes, Pro Justitia Law Journal, Vol.24, No.3
Rex Richard Sanjaya , 2020, Review Juridical Act Criminal Fraud Studies Case Decision Case Number 482/ Pid.B /2018/PN Blt , Journal of Supremacy, Vol. 10 Number 1
Rizkika Maharani Loventa, Analysis of District Court Decisions in Corruption Crime Cases by the Police of the Republic of Indonesia (Case Study Decision Number 01/Pid.Sus.Tpk/2017/PN. Mdn.), Batam International University Journal, Vol.1, No.1,
Rm Suharto, 2004, Prosecution and Judicial Practice, Jakarta, Sinar Graphics
RM. Surachman, Legal Mosaic I: 30 Selected Languages (Jakarta: Sumber Ilmu Jaya, 1996)
Romli Atmasasmita, 1996, Criminal Justice System, Bandung , Binabuat
Santoso M. A, 2014, Moral Law & Justice A Legal Study, Jakarta, Kencana, Second Printing
Seoroso, 2013, Introduction to Legal Studies, Jakarta, Sinar Graphics
Soerjono Soekanto & Sri Mamudj , 2001 , Study Law Normative ( A Overview Short ), Jakarta , Rajawali Pers
Sukardja Ahmad, 2012, Medina Charter and the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia, Jakarta, Sinar Pangganga
Sumadi , H. , 2016, Constraints in cope follow criminal fraud transaction electronics in Indonesia. Journal Outlook Juridica , Vol. 33 No.2
Tahir H. D, 2002, Discussion of Problems and Application of the Criminal Code Investigation and Prosecution, Jakarta Sinar Graphic
Ucuk Agiyanto , 2018 , Enforcement Law in Indonesia : Exploration Draft Justice Dimensional Divinity , Journal Scientific Law . Ponorogo : University Muhammadiyah Ponorogo .
The 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia
Law Number 16 of 2004 concerning the Prosecutor's Office of the Republic of Indonesia
Revelation Nugroho , 2009, Disparity Internal Judge's Decision Case Act Criminal Theft With weighting , Journal Major Jinayah Siyasa , Faculty Sharia State Islamic Institute Walisongo , (Semarang, 2009)
